The 3 Best Self Storage Stocks To Buy

In this post, I review the best self-storage stocks, so that you can make an informed decision about which self-storage REIT to buy.
9 Best Self Storage Stocks Reviewed

Contents

Key Takeaways

 

☑️ The three best self storage stocks are reviewed
☑️ The storage industry is recession-resistant

☑️
Six of the best storage stocks are from the U.S
☑️ Three are from Europe
☑️ The undisputed storage REIT is Public Storage

 

The Self Storage Industry – Explained

 

Self-storage is a massive industry. In fact, it is generating more revenue than Hollywood!

There are more storage facilities in the U.S., than Starbucks, McDonald’s, and Pizza Hut combined.

There are more than 60,000 storage facilities in the world. Of those, approx. 52,000 are in the United States, about 3,000 in Australia, 3,000 in Japan, and the remaining 2,000 in multiple countries.

Essentially all self storage stocks are real estate investment trusts (REITs). So for the remainder of the article, the terms self-storage stocks, mini storage stocks, or self-storage REITs, are used interchangeably.

 

 

Why Do People Use Self Storage?

The need for self-storage space is constantly increasing with the rise in population. Self-storage stocks have been at the forefront of this boom and have been providing quality storage space and services to their customers since the 1960s when Public Storage was founded.

In this article, I’ll review the world’s 9 best self storage stocks on the market, so that you can make an informed decision about your investment strategy.

 

 

Buy gold & silver bullion - Goldbroker.com

 

 

 

 

Are Storage REITs A Good Investment?

I have been personally engaged in the self-storage industry for years and spent a substantial amount of time studying the industry in detail. After having started my own self-storage company, you can see me as an ‘insider’, who had the opportunity to look behind the curtains of many leading self storage companies.

From my findings, the industry has excellent fundamentals, and almost all companies in the storage sector do reasonably well (see some of the tables below).

 

In Real Estate – Size Matters!

Let’s first take a look at the largest player in the entire real estate sector (not just self storage stocks):

Notice there are only two companies with net margins above 50%:

  • Prologis (PLD), an industrial warehouse REIT, and
  • Public Storage (PSA), see below.

No surprise, similar to other industries, the largest player benefits from economies of scale the most:

They typically get lower rates from their banking partners, they get lower construction fees per sqft/m2, their third-party expenses are spread across several properties, etc. That’s why it does not surprise that the three largest self storage stocks also have the best numbers.

Let’s begin by looking at the largest self storage stocks and storage REITs globally:

 

The Largest Self Storage REITs

 

 

Company Name M.Cap in Mio $ Sales in Bio $ PE Yield ROIC %
Public Storage 🇺🇸 51,142 3,825 25 2.8% 12%
Extra Space 🇺🇸 22,097 1,758 25 3.5% 9%
Life Storage 🇺🇸 8,537 904 27 4.1% 6%
CubeSmart 🇺🇸 8,462 922 35 4.6% 5%
Shurgard 🇪🇺 3,688 314 6 3.0% 4%
National Storage 🇺🇸 3,592 711 40 5.3% 5%
Big Yellow 🇬🇧 2,246 194 3 4.0% 5%
Safestore 🇬🇧 2,015 235 4 3.4% 5%
Smartstop 🇺🇸 1,322 192 0.0% 3%

 

 

 

 

 

Return On Assets Of The Best Storage Companies

 

Storage companies have very good average fundamentals.  Let’s for example look at the Return On Assets (ROA in %) of the five largest ones:

Return on Assets ROA of Self Storage Stocks

 

Net Margins Of The Best Self Storage Stocks

 

And let’s take a look at the average net margins of the top self storage stocks in the U.S.:

Net Margin % of Best Storage REITs

 

Do you know any other industries in which the “worst” player has a net margin of 25% or higher!?

 

PE Ratios Of The Leading Self Storage Stocks

PE Ratios of Best Self Storage Stocks

 

The 3x Best Self-Storage Stocks

 

Let us now review the three best self storage stocks. On spot 1 is Public Storage.

 

 🏆 Public Storage – The World’s Nr. 1 Storage Company

Public Storage Logo - Best Storage Stocks in the U.S.

 

 

The 800-pound gorilla in the room is the undisputed category leader, Public Storage.

Public Storage (PSA), is the oldest and largest storage REIT in the United States. It owns more than 2,500 facilities with a total of over 1 billion square feet of space. The company was founded in 1972 by businessman Harold Shoen and his son, Robert Shoen.

The company has grown to become the largest self-storage company in the world, owning Shurgard in Europe.

You might know Public Storage from its quite awesome storage TV commercials, such as this one:

 

 
🧐 Fun Fact #1: The Never-Loose Portfolio

Public Storage (PSA) is one of the five stocks of a unique and special model portfolio. With this portfolio consisting only of five stocks, you would have not had one year with a losing year! Every single year, your portfolio would be up. The five stocks are

  • Public Storage (PSA)
  • Nestle (NESM)
  • Church & Dwight (CHD)
  • 3M (MMM)
  • Walmart (WM)

Does Public Storage have a European subsidiary?

Yes, Public Storage owns 35% of Shurgard, Europe’s largest self-storage stock, which it acquired in 2006 for $5.5 Bio US. Later on, Shurgard was spun out into a publicly-traded entity and is now listed on the Euronext. Shurgard owns more than 250 self-storage facilities and storage space stretching over 1.3 Mio net rentable square meters in seven countries in Europe: the United Kingdom, Belgium, Germany, Netherlands, France, Sweden, and Denmark.

 

Fun Fact #2: Originally Private Storage

Did you know that Public Storage (PSA) originally was called ‘Private Storage’? But because potential customers who drove or walked by did not date to access the property because they thought it was private property, the name of the company was subsequently changed to Public Storage.

 

Life Storage – The Undisputed Nr. 2

Life Storage Logo - Best Storage Stocks in the U.S.

 

 

Although Life Storage (LSI) is only the third largest storage REIT in terms of facility count and turnover, it is clearly the strongest contender to Public Storage’s throne. $LSI is an equity REIT that acquires and manages self-storage facilities throughout the U.S.  Its headquarter is in Buffalo, New York, and it owns and operates +1,100 locations in +35 states.

I like the fact that $LSI puts the customer, and their unique stories, first. Just take these words, taken from their website:

“No one has ever decided out of the blue that they needed self-storage. No matter what life event brings you to our doorstep, Life Storage is here to help you hang onto the things that are important to you.”

 

🧐 Fun Fact #3: Uncle Bob

Before the companies merged, Life Storage also operated under the brand names  Sovran Self Storage, and Uncle Bob’s Self Storage

 

Extra Space Storage – Big But With Challenges

Extra Space Storage - Best Storage Stocks in the U.S.

 

 

Extra Space Storage (EXR), the number two in terms of owned/operated storage facilities and market cap.

It is a real estate investment trust headquartered in Cottonwood Heights, Utah, that invests in self-storage. It operates as a REIT and has been around for over 20 years. It currently operates about +2,000 facilities, in 41 states. It also provides property management services to third-party storage owners.

It is known for its savvy digital marketing and social media (the Extra Space Instagram account is worthwhile to check out). It is led by a charismatic CEO, Joseph Margolis (since 2017).

One thing to note is that Extra Space Storage lacks is in good customer reviews. It only has an average rating of 2,7 on Trustpilot, whereas Life Storage for example has 4.6 and Public Storage has 4.7. See the image further down below.

 

Which Self-Storage Company Gets The Best Reviews?

To find out, let’s turn to Trustpilot.com, one of the world’s most popular review sites. Public Storage (PSA) comes out on top with an average rating of 4.7, followed by Life Storage (LSI) with 4.6. Extra Space Self Storage (EXR) and Cube Smart Self Storage (CUBE) have pretty bad ratings with 2.7 and 2.5 respectively.

Customer Reviews of Best Self Storage Companies

 

Self-Storage Stocks Sample Portfolio

Over on SimplyWallstreet, I created a sample portfolio consisting of the before-mentioned three leading self-storage stocks. I also added two self-storage companies from Europe: Safestore and Shurgard. Click here to check them out.

Sample Portfolio of Good Self-Storage Stocks

 

I invested 10,000 USD of paper money into each of the five self-storage stocks. Now, one year later, the portfolio is down by about 9%, in line with the S&P500 (excl. dividends).

 

So, What Is The Best Storage Company To Invest In? 👇

 

Conclusion 

There you have it, folks. The best self storage stocks reviewed.

In my opinion, Public Storage with the ticker symbol $PSA ticks ALL boxes of an excellent buy-and-hold forever self storage stock!

A fortress-like balance sheet, excellent net margins, massive free cash flow, a good dividend, a recession-resistant business model, and wide-open potential to grow internationally.

My plan is to sell this dividend king, and buy $PSA instead.

 

📖 Read Also

 

How To Find Good Self-Storage Stocks

Total time needed: 5 minutes

Step 1: Head over to SimplyWall.St.

Best self-storage stocks - Step 1

SimplyWall.st is a great site allowing you to get a sense of the current valuation of specific stocks.

Step 2: Compare The 5x Best Self-Storage REITs.

Best self-storage stocks - Step 2

With the free plan, you can analyze up to five stocks. Look for the first one, e.g. National Storage Affiliate Trust (NSA), and on the top right menu next to ‘Add to watchlist‘ and ‘Add to portfolio‘, click on ‘Compare‘. Now, look For A Good ‘Share Price vs. Fair Value’ Ratio

Step 3: Compare Valuation Scores.

Best self-storage stocks - Step 3

SimplyWall.St’s in-house valuation algorithm is generally good at giving you a quick overview of how the particular self-storage stock compares to its peers. A higher valuation score (e.g. PSA’s 4 vs. EXR’s 2) is generally a good sign.

Step 4: Analyze the Price to Earnings Ratio vs Peers

Best self-storage stocks - Step 4

One SimplyWall.st chart I really love is the PE-to-Peers comparison. A quick glance is enough to see that Public Storage is valued relatively attractively, while NSA and CUBE appear a bit overpriced.

Step 5: Compare Dividend Yields

Best self-storage stocks - Step 5

Taking the dividend yield of $NSA as an example, we can see that it pays a high dividend yield, however, its dividend does not appear to be growing, and it also is not stable.

Supply:

  • right seach criteria
  • PE
  • dividend yield
  • valuation scores

Tools:

  • SimplyWall.st

 

Within a few minutes, SimplyWall.st helps you to analyze the five best self-storage stocks. Of course just because the site tells you that one specific stock is undervalued, you should go ahead and buy it. But it is an excellent starting point to begin your research process.

By using my invite link, you receive a 14-day free trial and unlimited company views so you can experience the platform’s full functionality for an extended period of time.

 

FAQs

 

How to find the best self-storage stocks?

Finding the best self-storage stock, also called storage REITs, is quite straightforward because there are less than a dozen publicly-listed self storage stocks, namely $PSA, $EXR, $LSI, $CUBE, $XBRU:SHUR, $NSA, $LSE:BYG, $STU:IHF and $STSFF. I’d look at those REITs with the highest ROIC, ROA, Funds from Operations/Assets, also called FFA, and lowest PE. As of 2023 January, the three best storage stocks are Public Storage (PSA), Extra Space Storage (EXR), and Life Storage (LFI).

After the Store Capital buyout, why not buy a self-storage REIT?

I am one of those Store Capital $STOR shareholders that needs to think about what to do with the proceeds of the sale of my $STOR stocks. As I already own several other REITs in my All-Weather Portfolio such as $O, $AVB, and $WELL, I am strongly considering buying $PSA instead.

Which storage REIT stock should I buy?

If you could only buy one self storage stock, I’d recommend Public Storage (PSA), without a doubt!  It’s the category pioneer, the largest storage REIT in the world, a good dividend payer, a highly profitable company with a fortress-like balance sheet, and a well-diversified asset portfolio.

Is the self-storage market saturated?

No. The self-storage market in the U.S. is still extremely fragmented. There are approx. 52,000 facilities in total, and the largest self-storage companies (see table above), only own about 10,000 in total. This means there is still a lot of room for new players to enter, or for existing players to consolidate and acquire smaller storage companies. The best self storage companies are reviewed in this post.

What are the 3 best storage REITs to buy?

The best self storage companies are located in the U.S. and are
$PSA – Public Storage
$LSI – Life Storage
$EXR – Extra Space
If you are looking for a good storage REIT in Europe, you can take a look at Shurgard.

What are the best self-storage stocks?

The best self storage stocks are Public Storage (PSA), Extra Space Storage (EXR), and Life Storage (LSI). These three have the highest ROIC (Return on Invested Capital), pay good dividends, and own thousands of storage facilities (no cluster risk, diversification, etc.).

What are the best self-storage stocks?

The best self storage stocks are Public Storage (PSA), Extra Space Storage (EXR), and Life Storage (LSI). These three have the highest ROIC (Return on Invested Capital), pay good dividends, and own thousands of storage facilities (no cluster risk, diversification, etc.).

How to invest in self storage stocks?

The best self storage stocks are listed on major exchanges such as the S&P500 or Russell 2000 meaning you can buy that at your preferred brokers.

Which self storage stocks are a good investment

As the self storage industry has strong fundamentals, most of the self storage stocks or storage REITs offer good risk/reward ratios. Public Storage is a cashflow-powerhouse, paying good dividends, owning +2,500 storage facilities all over the country (as well as all over Europe), and is a long-term favorite of income investors.

Why are self-storage stocks down in 2023?

Many self-storage stocks did not do well in 2023 due to the rapidly rising interest rates. Not all but some of the leading storage companies have high debt loads, and with increased interest expenses, they might not be able to be as profitable as before or see declining profit margins as interest costs go up.

Is Public Storage buying Life Storage?

Public Storage $PSA just announced an $11 Bio USD take-over bid for Life Storage, the 3rd largest and listed mini storage REIT in the world. It is now up to the shareholders of Life Storage to vote on the offer. Personally, I hope they vote “no” as Public Storage is already huge enough, and I believe it is better for the competition, and therefore us the consumer, to have at least 4-5 large storage REITs “fighting for our money”.

WiseStacker's Take

4.8 Score

I believe Public Storage (PSA) is the best self storage stock there is. It is the 800-pound self-storage gorilla, and offers everything you want in a self-storage you you can even buy-and-hold forever.

PROS

  • Excellent industry fundamtentals
  • Lowest CAPEX requirements (real estate sector)
  • Fortress-like balance sheet
  • Very high net margings ( 50%)
  • Stable and solid dividend
  • Large potential via capturing new regions

CONS

  • Storage business is not "sexy"
  • Higher interest rate make it harder to finance new properties

Review Breakdown

  • Financial Strength
  • Predictability
  • Growth Rank
  • Dividend
  • Overall Rating

Recent Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
Please agree to the privacy terms
2 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

About Me

Hi there, I’m Noah, an avid DIY investor on a quest for wealth & wisdom. I’m sharing my portfolio, trades & dividend income so you can learn from my missteps! Sign up for my 100% free newsletter to get updates.

Freedom Stats

🧑🏻‍🌾 Age when reaching FI: 40 in 2018
😰 Left the rat race: May 2017
🏠 Living in: Singapore
👨‍👨‍👧‍👦 Number of kids: 2
💵 Net Worth: $6.5 Mio US
☂️ All-Weather Portfolio: $1.02 Mio
🍭
Dividend Income (2023): $25k
🌳
Passive Income (2023):
$157k
💵
Crypto Portfolio: $2.0 Mio
♥️
My 10 Favorite Dividend Stocks

Disclaimer

I’m not a financial advisor. Please do your own research & read the disclaimer. No content is meant to be a recommendation. Some pages might contain affiliate links that won’t cost you anything.

My Top Content

🤟Services I Love

For stock research: SeekingAlpha
For in-depth research: Gurufocus
For buying Bitcoin & crypto: Nexo
For
buying gold: Goldbroker
For pension saving: Getpenfold
For storing crypto: Ledger Wallet

Recent Posts​

Search

Join My Email List

Check out my passive income.
100% free. No spam. 
Unsub anytime.

financial newsletter for dividend stocks

Join My Free Email List

Ahoy, captain of your own financial destiny! Ready to hoist the sails towards serene financial freedom?

My spam-free, no-cost emails will map the market seas, and steer you towards independence. Unsub anytime! Bonus – Instantly unlock my passive income!